Tax Loss Harvesting with Behavioral Finance

Turning portfolio losses into long-term advantages

Most investors leave thousands of dollars on the table every year not because they can’t pick good stocks, but because they can’t bring themselves to sell bad ones.

In investing, losses are inevitable. Even the most successful investors experience downturns (even if they don’t talk about it). What defines elite investors isn’t how they achieve big gains but how they manage losses, and now you, too can take advantage of this underused strategy to increase your wealth.

Prospect theory shows we dislike losses roughly twice as much as we enjoy gains. That emotional aspect makes us hold losers too long. Tax loss harvesting flips the script: it rewards you for doing the one thing your brain wants you to avoid. (We’ve covered it in previous articles).

If you struggle to sell a losing stock, there’s an effective strategy that incentivizes investors to take advantage of a loss called tax loss harvesting.

This Prof of Wall Street primer will explain the benefits, costs, and behavioral methods of tax loss harvesting so you can improve performance and help you reach your financial goals faster.

What Is Tax Loss Harvesting?

Tax loss harvesting is selling investments at a loss to offset capital gains or reduce taxable income. You’re “harvesting” losing positions to grow your wealth, which is counterintuitive.

Here’s how tax loss harvesting works:

You sell an investment (like a stock, ETF, or mutual fund) worth less than what you paid, thereby “realizing” the loss (versus a “paper loss” that sits in your account).
You use that realized loss to offset capital gains from other investments in this or previous years.
If your losses exceed your gains, you can use up to $3,000 per year in the US ($1,500 if married filing separately) to reduce your ordinary income, carrying any remaining losses forward (last time we checked, Canada had no limit).

It’s one of the few times the tax code rewards you for losing money as long as you “follow the rules.”

A Simple Example

Suppose you sold Stock A for a $10,000 profit earlier this year. Later, you notice Stock B in your portfolio is down $8,000 from your purchase price. By selling Stock B and realizing that loss, your net capital gain drops from $10,000 to $2,000 — reducing your tax bill. If you’re in the 20% long-term capital gains bracket, that’s $1,600 in tax savings.

So if you check your portfolio in December and notice two stocks down 40%, instead of waiting and hoping they bounce back, harvesting those losses today could reduce your tax bill, tighten your portfolio, and set you up with a stronger starting point for next year.

The Wash Sale Rule (and Why It Matters)

A critical caveat: the wash sale rule. If you sell a security at a loss and buy the same (or “substantially identical”) security within 30 days before or after the sale, the IRS disallows the loss for tax purposes (and the CRA likewise forbids it).

In plain English: you can’t sell losing shares on December 31 and buy them back on January 2 to secure a deduction.

Instead, you can:

Buy a similar but not identical asset (e.g., sell an S&P 500 ETF and buy a total market ETF).
Wait 31 days before repurchasing the same asset.

This rule prevents “paper losses” from being used for tax manipulation.

When Tax Loss Harvesting Works Most Effectively

Tax loss harvesting is effective when:

You have taxable investment accounts (not IRAs or 401(k)s).
You have realized gains to offset.
You have volatile assets (such as individual stocks) that experience meaningful price fluctuations, a common experience for investors.

It benefits long-term investors during market downturns. Rebalancing your portfolio or replacing underperforming holdings with better ones aligns with tax-loss harvesting.

Why People Struggle to ‘Pull the Trigger’

There are many articles about this topic, but none address the core problem of why people who know about this method often avoid selling losers and taking advantage of tax loss harvesting.

As mentioned earlier, people avoid crystallizing a loss due to loss aversion. When in a losing position, they gamble on their losses in the hope that the price reverses and “undoes” the loss.

Not only this, but people fall prey to another bias known as the sunk cost fallacy and often double- or triple-down on losing positions in an attempt to recover losses in behavior known as loss chasing (check out our articles on this, we have at least four).

How Behavioral Fintech Helps Investors Tax-Loss Harvest

We built a powerful yet easy-to-use investment process that every investor can use. We integrated actions such as tax-loss harvesting to prime investors to take advantage of this tax-reduction maneuver and practice selling losing stocks when there’s a compelling economic reason to do so. If you’re interested in using this unique investment process, reach out.

Final Takeaway: Turning Losses Into Long-Term Gains

Tax loss harvesting is one of the few moments where the tax code rewards you for doing something emotionally difficult: realizing a loss.

By integrating behavioral finance with smart tax strategy, you can:

reduce your tax burden
avoid loss chasing
maintain discipline
and accelerate long-term wealth building

If you want help understanding how emotions affect your decisions—or want behavioral analytics that reveal where your investing process is costing you money—reach out today. Prof of Wall Street helps investors act with clarity, confidence, and data-driven insight.

We empower investors like you to make the most of a bad situation and practice something counterintuitive and uncomfortable with clear benefits. The goal here is that you will recognize yourself and be one of the few to leverage behavioral finance to grow your wealth, even if it’s uncomfortable.

FAQ: Tax Loss Harvesting

Is tax loss harvesting worth it?

Yes. For many investors, it reduces taxes, improves long-term after-tax returns, and encourages disciplined decision-making.

Can you buy the same stock after tax loss harvesting?

Yes—after 30 days. Buying sooner triggers a wash sale.

Does tax loss harvesting work with ETFs?

Absolutely. Many investors harvest losses in ETFs and rotate into similar but not identical funds.

Does tax loss harvesting hurt long-term performance?

Not when done prudently. Over-harvesting can create tracking error, but thoughtful TLH generally improves after-tax returns.

Does tax loss harvesting work in Canada?

Yes. Canada uses the “superficial loss rule,” which is similar to the U.S. wash sale rule.

Can tax loss harvesting be done every year?

Yes. Many investors harvest losses annually or opportunistically during market volatility.

‍

Helpful Links

WSJ article: https://www.wsj.com/finance/investing/tax-loss-harvesting-valuable-tax-breaks-11638390838?mod=hp_jr_pos1

"Optimized Tax Loss Harvesting: A Simple Algorithm and Framework" (Israelov and Lu, '22)

"Tax-Loss Harvesting: An Individual Investor’s Perspective" (Kang et al '21)
‍

Notes on Risk

Tax-loss harvesting involves certain risks, including, among others, the risk that the new investment could perform worse than the original investment and that transaction costs could offset the tax benefit. There may also be unintended tax implications. We recommend that you consult a tax advisor before taking action.

All investing is subject to risk, including possible loss of principal. Past performance is no guarantee of future results.

‍